October 13, 2000, Madison Square Garden; New York, NY
Set List: (both solo acoustic) I Am A Patriot by Steven Van Zandt,
The Times They Are A-Changin' by Bob Dylan
Brian SaenzDeViteri (bsbeamer@yahoo.com):
Friday the 13th, nothing can be luckier than that!
Ralph Nader and his loyal team of supporters and
voters gathered in the amazing and spectacular Madison
Square Garden for a rally to "Let Ralph Debate" as its
main driving force. The first time since 1971 that
Nader had been able to speak in MSG, and that time was
to end the building of more nuclear power plants.
I went to this rally as a first-time voter concerned
with the issues and I am glad that many of them were
finally being talked about where I could hear and see
them. Since the Nader campaign has been lacking any
mainstream press, it is very hard to get firsthand
information anywhere other than Nader’s website,
www.votenader.org. Phil Donahue opened up the night
and got the crowd going. Shortly after his opening
speech, local Green Party candidates and supporters
briefly took the stage. The filmmaker Michael Moore
discussed issues such as campaign funding, corporate
welfare and the lack of a difference between Gore and
Bush. Susan Sarandon spoke and focused on voting your
conscience. Bill Murray, dressed in orange army
fatigue pants, gray sweater, and taupe sport jacket
talked about the importance of everyone getting out to
vote and representing your vote. Tim Robbins came out
as "Bob Roberts" and sang two songs pretending to be a
Bush supporter. Ben Harper was amazing as usual and
performed two songs, including Sexual Healing. Ani
DiFranco was her usual scatting voice and beautiful.
Patti Smith performed three songs and was amazing! I
am extremely glad I was able to hear her sing,
especially for her first time performing at MSG.
Eddie Vedder was the last "celebrity" to take the
stage. He came out with his notebook and his acoustic
to a roaring applause and screams by the entire
audience. Ed introduced himself a little and spoke
very briefly to the audience before performing "I Am A
Patriot." He says, "I am no longer a Democrat, sure as
fuck ain’t no Republican either." Then he talked about
not having enough time to write a song for this, and
someone screamed "You can do it!" and Ed started
laughing. He said that if there was a day or two more
he could have done it maybe, but since today was the
registration deadline in New York, he did not have
enough time. So he is using this next song with
permission of the author and it is more fitting now
than maybe it has ever been. So he performs "The Times
Are A Changing." After the first few notes, the Garden
goes mad! Truly spoke the feeling of the arena at that
point.
To my surprise, for every person that performed or
spoke, the Garden was silent. Everyone respected the
artists and wanted to hear what they had to say. That
alone was one of the most inspiring moments in my
life. Close to 16,000 people, a sold-out crowd, silent
when someone had the mic. AMAZING!
After Ed’s short solo acoustic set, it was time for
the "host" of this amazing party to take center stage.
The crowd chants "Let’s Go Nader" and it was as loud
as the chants the Rangers get during the playoffs!
(For anyone who knows anything about MSG, the Rangers
play there and their chant "Let’s Go Rangers" has been
their chant for 75 years now.) Then Michael Moore
comes out and introduces Ralph Nader. He is swarmed
with applause and confetti dropped from the ceiling.
He is on the stage almost five minutes before he can
even get a word in. Very moving display by the
audience.
Nader talked about almost every issue he supports and
highlighted his platform for running for president.
Almost everything he thought was discussed. Some of
the issues were: organic farming, small business, the
"Republicrat" party, the lack of the debate for the
debates, putting the debates back in the hands of the
people, major health care reform, free tuition for
college students at public universities, cutbacks in
government spending especially in defense spending,
providing a stable economy for everyone to make a
decent income, raising the real dollars earned, ending
the WTO, and having this moment as the starting point
for a change in the way things are done in this
country. Nader spoke about each of these issues as a
well-informed person and spoke in a language we can
understand. He did not use loaded words, he did not
try and impress anyone, he just spoke to the people,
as a representative of the people.
After Nader’s speech, all the performers and speakers
took the stage for a final performance. Patti Smith
led the song "The Time For Change Is Now" and it
turned into a 10 minute jam with Patti Smith’s
guitarist, Ben Harper, and Eddie Vedder all on guitar
backing Patti Smith. Eddie added some backing vocals
as well as Susan Sarandon. Susan Sarandon was standing
next to Eddie and was "Doing the Evolution" dance that
Ed has made famous now while he was jamming out on his
guitar. "Let Ralph Debate" became the ending chorus
for the song, and truly the words that this rally
should be all about.
A very inspiring night for a positive change to happen
in the future. It reminded me of all the gatherings I
have seen about the movements in the 60s that made a
change. This event has that caliber to make a change
happen in this country. We just have to let our voice
be heard! I believe it was Bill Murray that said all
of the presidents at Mount Rushmore are third party
candidates or not affiliated with a party at all.
George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, Theodore
Roosevelt, and Abraham Lincoln all made a positive
change in this country and got us moving in the right
direction. Ralph Nader is the next to be added to the
Mount Rushmore listing of third party candidates that
make a positive change happen.
|